← Back to Etsy
Compare
Etsy vs OfferUp
Etsy and OfferUp are both marketplaces. On a $1,000 payment you keep about $904.55 on Etsy and $1,000 on OfferUp, before withdrawal or currency-conversion costs.
Updated · from each platform’s published fees and payout terms · how we verify
Key differences
- On a $1,000 payment you keep about $904.55 on Etsy and $1,000 on OfferUp, before withdrawal or currency-conversion costs.
- Only Etsy offers Bank transfer. Only OfferUp offers Paid in person by the buyer at local meetups.
- Etsy is the older platform — founded in 2005, 6 years before OfferUp (2011).
- OfferUp focuses on the United States, while Etsy operates internationally.
Which should you choose?
Choose Etsy if…
- You want to withdraw via Bank transfer.
- You prefer a long track record (since 2005).
Choose OfferUp if…
- Keeping more of each payment matters most — its fee is lower.
- You want to withdraw via Paid in person by the buyer at local meetups.
- You live in the United States.
Side by side
|
Etsy
The leading marketplace for handmade goods, craft supplies, and vintage items. Anyone can open a shop, list pr…
Visit
|
OfferUp
A large US marketplace app for selling used goods to local buyers.
Visit
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Type | Marketplaces like Etsy | Marketplaces like Etsy |
| Category | Selling & Resale | Selling & Resale |
| Vetted | No | No |
| Work from home | Yes | No |
| Fees | 6.5% transaction fee + 3% + $0.25 payment processing (US) + $0.20 listing fee | No fees on local sales, shipping ended Oct 2025, paid listings over free limits |
| Payout speed | Daily, weekly, biweekly or monthly deposits, 1-5 business days to bank | — |
| Withdraw via | Bank transfer (Etsy Payments) | Paid in person by the buyer (cash) at local meetups |
| Availability | Sellers in 60+ Etsy Payments countries, buyers worldwide | United States |
| Local to | — | United States |
| Founded | 2005 | 2011 |
| Headquarters | Brooklyn, New York, United States | Bellevue, United States |
| Stock ticker | NASDAQ: ETSY | — |
| Popularity | 41 views · 0 likes | 37 views · 0 likes |
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper, Etsy or OfferUp?
On a $1,000 payment you keep about $904.55 on Etsy and $1,000 on OfferUp, before withdrawal or currency-conversion costs.
Where are Etsy and OfferUp available?
Etsy: Sellers in 60+ Etsy Payments countries, buyers worldwide. OfferUp: United States.